Specifically

I--and I've known this all along--am not wired for abstract thought. I reduce everything to the specific, the personal. It's the only way I can think something through. I've always taken it as a weakness. It appears, though, that abstract thinkers err the other way: they can tend--whether by impulse or inability--to discount the personal. Amita's work--in disability, in identity, in adoption--sits there, at the place where person and principle meet. Maybe that's the language of the UN, and though I know that institution is flawed and vulnerable, I'm also touched to think of grownups from around the world coming together to talk and think cross-culturally about human life--in principle and in the specific.
* * *
It's been a busy week--getting the shack ready for company, working toward gainful employment, helping Maisie build a model longhouse out of twigs and bark. I wrote to Maisie's teacher about homework: too much of it; there's supposed to be a half-hour of it in the third grade, but the night I wrote to the teacher Maisie had been at it for 2 hours and was still going strong. Teacher writes back to tell me that "many, many families" had said THEIR children were whipping the stuff out in less than half an hour and wanted more. She was defensive. I expected it: I'd also tucked into my little note criticism of her tactic of reading just the first sentence of the kids' essays and then saying--in front of the whole class--"BO-ring." She tried to defend it: called it a pedagogical tool. Poor, poor thing--she's young, and has no idea what she's up against. We're meeting this morning.
Talk about your specifics...
Nice to be missed, though. I'll catch up with everyone in the next few days.
16 Comments:
I would have loved to hear Amita speak.
I would love to be a fly on the wall for the meeting with the teacher.
I would love to take you to lunch.
rQm
At some point they have to learn that Some Teachers Are Idiots and Ohers Are Mean. Third grade, alas, is a little young.
I remember in third grade they had some new-fangled math they were supposed to teach ("borrrowing" instead of "carrrying" or some such). The day before the inspecttor came, the teacher taught us the new official vocabulary. When Her
Eminence left, we went back to doing it the old way. A more important lesson in bureaucracy than in arithmetic, which I managed to learn anyway.
Suffer Foold Gladly. Not a bad life lesson, even if it's painful to go through it.
Oops. "Fools," not "Foold."
Guess I am one. Suffer me gladly.
Love the photo! Love it more since I am sitting here in a nice warm house...
I too like the idea of the U.N. and that someone is trying to do something about any of the myriad of issues that confront our world each day. From the little acorns like your friends presentation, perhaps an oak will grow!
Good luck at your meeting; I'd like to have a seat next to RQM!
alan
Firstly, loved your Photo Sunday post. Your words are awesome and eloquent. I am touched by adoption in a couple of ways and I know exactly what you mean about having a connection with someone that surpasses biology.
As for Amita and the UN...I don't think I'm smart enough to be even a fly on the wall (grin).
I remember third grade with a wince. I didn't like my third grade teacher and that stuck with me for a long time. Ironically, I loved, loved, loved teaching third grade!!! Tell Maisie to hang in there. That dingy teacher has no clue as to what's comin' her way!
OH that is really mean. BORING! Who is the adult here? I thought the teachers were suppose to stop the kids from doing stuff like that. Can't wait to here how THAT meeting went.
Glad to see you up and blogging again. I would also have loved to heard your friend speak.
Girlfriend you know so many interesting people. It just never amazes me.
As far as the teacher goes, that woman should be shot for making the BOR-ing comments.... The homework thing is a different issue, so many kids just dash through all their work. I have kids in my class that get an assignment done in 5 minutes that could take a kid as smart as them 30 minutes. My guess is that Maisie's house was perfect and the others were not. She should listen to all the parents and find a way to give more to those who ask for it, not make comments that other kids get done in less then 30 minutes. Those damn teachers!!!!
So how was the meeting????
I would love to have you for a parent in my classroom, I would put you to work!!
yes we all want to know how the meeting went!!...do tell!!
peace...
~ n
xoxox
another post that pulls on my mama heart strings, inger!
first, your amazing friend. what a wondrous role model for your kids she must be. i am in awe. after imagining being there for my whole life, i finally got to viisit the u.n. two years ago, when i was in n.y.c. for my youngest child's choral competetion. it was a special day for me-especially sharing it with my daughter. i still remember how excited my own mom was, when she was there for the first time. my upbringing was such that we always believed that the u.n. was not perfect, but it was quite neccesary/big picture.
as for some teachers. ouch. even after all the yearts, and all the teachers my 3 have had, some things still piss me off. the other side is that sometimes our kids get teachers that enhance their lives in countless ways.
meanwhile, it's a great thing that maisie has YOU as her champion! lucky child, she.
Boring? You tell a third grader that their work is boring?
Can we bring back the firing squad with spit balls please. Put this young women in front of it and fire away!
Uping the ante, I'd like to make you lunch (although rQm is a much better cook than I.)
xo
STB
All these lunch invitations, what a lucky woman. Hey, I will make you dinner and even buy the wine if you want to come for dinner.
For that matter rQm, Alan and STB can come also.
Mary
I hate when children learn the harshness of life thru experiences like this. But GOM is right, they do have to learn, but why so young?!?!?!?
~Deb
hate to overloads of homework kids get these days...my homeschooled neices and nephews are done their entire workday in the time it took my kids to do their homework some times.
Loved your tribute to "Jim"
GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRrrrr
Please update us on the idiot opps I mean...new and inexperienced...teacher situation.
I feel like storming into that class with you and setting her straight....in a nice calm rational don't argue with me way of course.
We are having the same issues here. The elementary school has been great in responding....the JrHigh is a whole different thing.
OH AND....I don't UNDERSTAND parents asking for MORE homework! What? They don't want their children to have ANY time enjoying being kids?
Sorry....this one pushed a hot button...can ya tell?
WOAH WOAH WOAH. I can't believe she would say that in front of the class. But you know what? I find that some people think the best tool for teaching is to criticize. My fiance (happened over christmas) is at the air force academy and they are definitely not into affirming the positive. And since Maurice has been there for a while, it has kind of sunk into his brain. I tell him over and over that not everyonen learns by being told they are stupid and that I actually am more likely to excel by someone affirming the positive in what I am already doing. We are working to find the balance between the two. I like it that you are such a strong advocate for your children. Trust me, in such a harsh and unkind world THEY NEED YOU. TTYL. Anna
Oh my, I've done battle with a few teachers in my time too and although unpleasant, is sometimes necessary. Good luck.
Post a Comment
<< Home